Fair Haven's bait & tackle shop

One of the longest-running businesses in Fair Haven, NY, still serving the anglers who fish the bay and Lake Ontario.

Screwy Louie's has been a Fair Haven fixture since 1984, under the same name the whole way. The retail store is now owned and operated by Brian DiBernardo, who's keeping what locals love about the shop and adding more: a bigger tackle selection, an online store, and the same straight answers about what's biting.

1984

Serving Fair Haven since

7 days

Open every week

Cannon & Scotty

Authorized repair shop

Live bait

Stocked fresh so you can grab it on the way to the launch.

Tackle & apparel

Rods, reels, lures, ice gear and Screwy Louie's caps and hoodies.

Downrigger repair

Authorized service for Cannon and Scotty downriggers.

Local know-how

Ask us what's working on the bay and the big lake.

Stop in before you hit the water

596 Main Street, Sterling, NY. Open 7 days.

Get directions